Club Admiralty

v7.2 - moving along, a point increase at a time

Multilitteratus Incognitus

Pondering what to learn next 🤔

Kicking off the lit-review (2.0)

With the summer here, and all of my doctoral coursework behind me, we are firmly in the self-determination area of the game-board.  No external pressures, no external timelines (although there is a statute of limitations on the degree), and interim assignments.  The dissertation proposal is it! That's the next target (which I am hoping to meet by December 2017).

I already have a literature review done, but I was really eclectic in putting it together.  The lit-review (albeit incomplete and in need of some tightening) does present facets of what might be happening underneath it all when it comes to collaboration amongst self-formed groups in open educational experiences, but it doesn't work all that well when providing a grounding for collaboration amongst learners. In other words, I skipped to the chase even though I haven't formally collected data or spoken to other my study participants yet. I am just theorizing from past observations.

In any case, that old lit-review is currently scrapped. It may come in handy later, but I need to focus on the foundational stuff first.  That said, I did a few searches in databases, looking for full-text, peer-reviewed, materials on collaboration in educational contexts. I ended up finding around 200 articles that may be of use (out of several thousand results for my key terms). I also looked for relevant articles on MOOC demographics (to get a sense of who's who in terms of the people involved on the learner side of things in MOOCs).  Finally, I raided my stash of articles that I've been compiling (hoarding for future reading...whenever there is time) since 2011 when I first got involved with MOOCs. This stockpile also contained articles that were of relevance mostly to a previous (dropped) dissertation ideas, but have relevant to the one I am working now.

All things said, I have around 420 peer reviewed articles that look promising, plus 6 or 8 books on collaboration.  That's a lot of reading.  It's also highly likely that I will find stuff in the references section of those articles that I will need to track down because those articles seem of interest.  So, there are two questions that come to mind:

1. Is this overkill?  Now, not all of the articles will prove to be useful and they will go on my reject pile, but even assuming a 20% relevancy of references (80 articles) and a 10% relevancy from those reference's references, that's 588 articles to shift through, which makes for a potentially huge literature review.

2. What is the best way to track your readings (beyond Mendeley, RefWorks, and the like)? Whenever I read there are tons of marginalia, underlined text, and highlighted text. Things that may come in handy later...but may just as well be left on the cutting room floor.  Neither the PDF format, nor the paper format really satisfied me. I feel like I am either putting a ton of work into copy/pasting all of my notes into Google docs but a lot of times I end up using at most 20% (at most 40%)  of that stuff.  It's great note taking, but not sure it is good use of my time.  Then again with articles (especially digital ones!)  I fear that my thoughts in my marginalia are invisible to me because they are simply not collated in one place.

3. (OK I lied, there are 3 things):  How likely is it that I am experiencing academic FOMO with regard to item #2?


I guess rubber meets road this weekend.  I think I'll kick off by re-doing my introduction.  Most introductions I've seen are about twice as long as my draft intro, so it's time to go back, see what I wrote, and provide a little more focus and depth to my intro.  My goal for this time next week: have a new introduction.
 Comments
Stacks Image 20

Archive

 Aug 2022 (1)
 Jul 2022 (1)
 Jun 2022 (1)
 May 2022 (2)
 Mar 2022 (2)
 Dec 2021 (2)
 Oct 2021 (1)
 Sep 2021 (1)
 Aug 2021 (2)
 Jul 2021 (1)
 Jun 2021 (1)
 Nov 2020 (1)
 Oct 2020 (1)
 Sep 2020 (1)
 Jun 2020 (2)
 May 2020 (2)
 Mar 2020 (1)
 Jan 2020 (3)
 Nov 2019 (2)
 Sep 2019 (1)
 Aug 2019 (1)
 Jun 2019 (1)
 May 2019 (1)
 Apr 2019 (1)
 Jan 2019 (5)
 Dec 2018 (1)
 Nov 2018 (2)
 Oct 2018 (2)
 Jul 2018 (1)
 May 2018 (1)
 Apr 2018 (2)
 Mar 2018 (2)
 Feb 2018 (1)
 Jan 2018 (1)
 Dec 2017 (2)
 Nov 2017 (1)
 Oct 2017 (2)
 Sep 2017 (2)
 Aug 2017 (2)
 Jul 2017 (4)
 Jun 2017 (7)
 May 2017 (3)
 Mar 2017 (4)
 Feb 2017 (5)
 Jan 2017 (5)
 Dec 2016 (9)
 Nov 2016 (1)
 Oct 2016 (6)
 Sep 2016 (4)
 Aug 2016 (7)
 Jul 2016 (8)
 Jun 2016 (9)
 May 2016 (10)
 Apr 2016 (12)
 Mar 2016 (13)
 Feb 2016 (7)
 Jan 2016 (11)
 Dec 2015 (10)
 Nov 2015 (7)
 Oct 2015 (5)
 Sep 2015 (8)
 Aug 2015 (9)
 Jul 2015 (7)
 Jun 2015 (7)
 May 2015 (15)
 Apr 2015 (2)
 Mar 2015 (10)
 Feb 2015 (4)
 Jan 2015 (7)
 Dec 2014 (5)
 Nov 2014 (13)
 Oct 2014 (10)
 Sep 2014 (8)
 Aug 2014 (8)
 Jul 2014 (5)
 Jun 2014 (5)
 May 2014 (3)
 Apr 2014 (4)
 Mar 2014 (8)
 Feb 2014 (10)
 Jan 2014 (10)
 Dec 2013 (4)
 Nov 2013 (8)
 Oct 2013 (6)
 Sep 2013 (10)
 Aug 2013 (6)
 Jul 2013 (4)
 Jun 2013 (3)
 May 2013 (2)
 Apr 2013 (8)
 Mar 2013 (4)
 Feb 2013 (10)
 Jan 2013 (11)
 Dec 2012 (3)
 Nov 2012 (8)
 Oct 2012 (17)
 Sep 2012 (15)
 Aug 2012 (16)
 Jul 2012 (19)
 Jun 2012 (12)
 May 2012 (12)
 Apr 2012 (12)
 Mar 2012 (12)
 Feb 2012 (13)
 Jan 2012 (14)
 Dec 2011 (19)
 Nov 2011 (21)
 Oct 2011 (31)
 Sep 2011 (12)
 Aug 2011 (8)
 Jul 2011 (7)
 Jun 2011 (3)
 May 2011 (2)
 Apr 2011 (8)
 Mar 2011 (5)
 Feb 2011 (6)
 Jan 2011 (6)
 Dec 2010 (3)
 Nov 2010 (2)
 Oct 2010 (2)
 Sep 2010 (4)
 Aug 2010 (9)
 Jul 2010 (8)
 Jun 2010 (5)
 May 2010 (4)
 Apr 2010 (2)
 Mar 2010 (3)
 Feb 2010 (7)
 Jan 2010 (9)
 Dec 2009 (5)
 Nov 2009 (9)
 Oct 2009 (13)
 Sep 2009 (13)
 Aug 2009 (13)
 Jul 2009 (13)
 Jun 2009 (15)
 May 2009 (15)
 Apr 2009 (14)
 Mar 2009 (13)
 Feb 2009 (10)
 Jan 2009 (12)
 Dec 2008 (6)
 Nov 2008 (8)
 Oct 2008 (2)
 Jul 2008 (1)
 Jun 2008 (6)
 May 2008 (1)
Stacks Image 18