Club Admiralty

v7.2 - moving along, a point increase at a time

Multilitteratus Incognitus

Pondering what to learn next πŸ€”

Groups, cooperatives, collaboratives, swarms...and the ongoing dissertation proposal...

It's been quite a while since I last shared a few thoughts.  I guess time flies even if you aren't having fun πŸ˜†. In the past few weeks I've been contemplating the direction of my dissertation proposal.  I am not changing topics (now THAT would be silly, and an unnecessary amount of work), but I am considering the framing of my argument.  The topic (just to refresh your mind) is "Why do we collaborate?" and it's an exploration of the emergent groups that formed in Rhizo14 and rhizo15 to conduct some sort of academic work in order to figure out why we did this (after all, everyone hates group work, right??? 😜) This academic work wasn't part of the original Rhizo-course plan†, so why the heck did we band together to do this type of work?

The question, I should point out (again) wasn't originally mine - I just took an interest in it.  Rebecca H. had originally asked this question of our MobiMOOC team back in 2011/2012 - but we all went (sort of) our separate ways and we just hadn't explored it in depth at the time; and this seemed like a good question for dissertation research (and I found it interesting, so it checked off that internal motivation box), and there were enough people in Rhizos collaborating in groups that made for a viable case study.

Now, one of my stumbling blocks has been terminology. I started off calling what we did (in our various groups) a 'collaboration'.  But, collaboration has certain specific connotations.  Was it really collaboration?  Or did I just see what we did (and what others did, for groups I wasn't part of) as collaboration?  Is a "swarm" different from collaboration? Or is it a specific type of collaboration? It should also be noted that not all work was 'swarmed'.  Part way through this gargantuan proposal I started replacing collaboration with group work, which seems more value neutral than collaboration, this way as part of the research I can see how different people perceived the joint-effort we/they accomplished as somewhere on the 'working together' spectrum.    Is there a word that is value neutral (or mostly value neutral) that rolls off the tongue that means "3 or more people working together on a common goal"?

But I still have a little trouble with the term "group work".  For me it harkens back to school days where teachers put us in groups to do something together that wasn't always of interest to the learner, and people were placed in a situation where they had to work together but it was just awkward (my experiences in the rhizo work didn't feel awkward).   Is the term "team work" more appropriate? Is it more value neutral?  A team may be more self forming...maybe...but it also reminds me of the artificial aspects of corporate 'teams' where work gets done (I think), but there really isn't much camaraderie.  In my experience there was camaraderie in the collaborations I was in...at least from my own observations.

That said, this bring me to the next stumbling block. How did I see this thing/action/project/collective that had/have?   Do I address my own views about the collaborations Ive been part of in the introductory chapter to my proposal/dissertation?  Or do I save it for my data collection section (self-interviews and journaling) as some research methods books suggest? Or, is there a good mid-point where I can address potential biases by discussing it a bit (but how much is enough?) and then saving the rest for the data collection portion?

When the researcher is part of the researched it makes things a little muddy.  Things that are 'clear' in my head aren't necessarily things that are transmitted as 'clear' to the eventual audience of my doctoral work. I think part of the problem is that my direct experience really colors my perceptions (as I expected it would), but also that the question "why did we do this?" is intentionally broad. Would it be helpful to narrow it down to a specific aspect of our work together? And, if yes, what specific aspect would be of most interest to this community I am researching (and am a member of)?  Loads of questions...


OK, that's all the reflecting for now.  What do others think?





Marginalia:
† Although, with the mindset of "the community is the curriculum", one could argue that such group work was part of the curriculum.  Cormier! you evil genius! 😈
 Comments
Stacks Image 20

Archive

 Sep 2022 (2)
 Aug 2022 (3)
 Jul 2022 (1)
 Jun 2022 (1)
 May 2022 (2)
 Mar 2022 (2)
 Dec 2021 (2)
 Oct 2021 (1)
 Sep 2021 (1)
 Aug 2021 (2)
 Jul 2021 (1)
 Jun 2021 (1)
 Nov 2020 (1)
 Oct 2020 (1)
 Sep 2020 (1)
 Jun 2020 (2)
 May 2020 (2)
 Mar 2020 (1)
 Jan 2020 (3)
 Nov 2019 (2)
 Sep 2019 (1)
 Aug 2019 (1)
 Jun 2019 (1)
 May 2019 (1)
 Apr 2019 (1)
 Jan 2019 (5)
 Dec 2018 (1)
 Nov 2018 (2)
 Oct 2018 (2)
 Jul 2018 (1)
 May 2018 (1)
 Apr 2018 (2)
 Mar 2018 (2)
 Feb 2018 (1)
 Jan 2018 (1)
 Dec 2017 (2)
 Nov 2017 (1)
 Oct 2017 (2)
 Sep 2017 (2)
 Aug 2017 (2)
 Jul 2017 (4)
 Jun 2017 (7)
 May 2017 (3)
 Mar 2017 (4)
 Feb 2017 (5)
 Jan 2017 (5)
 Dec 2016 (9)
 Nov 2016 (1)
 Oct 2016 (6)
 Sep 2016 (4)
 Aug 2016 (7)
 Jul 2016 (8)
 Jun 2016 (9)
 May 2016 (10)
 Apr 2016 (12)
 Mar 2016 (13)
 Feb 2016 (7)
 Jan 2016 (11)
 Dec 2015 (10)
 Nov 2015 (7)
 Oct 2015 (5)
 Sep 2015 (8)
 Aug 2015 (9)
 Jul 2015 (7)
 Jun 2015 (7)
 May 2015 (15)
 Apr 2015 (2)
 Mar 2015 (10)
 Feb 2015 (4)
 Jan 2015 (7)
 Dec 2014 (5)
 Nov 2014 (13)
 Oct 2014 (10)
 Sep 2014 (8)
 Aug 2014 (8)
 Jul 2014 (5)
 Jun 2014 (5)
 May 2014 (3)
 Apr 2014 (4)
 Mar 2014 (8)
 Feb 2014 (10)
 Jan 2014 (10)
 Dec 2013 (4)
 Nov 2013 (8)
 Oct 2013 (6)
 Sep 2013 (10)
 Aug 2013 (6)
 Jul 2013 (4)
 Jun 2013 (3)
 May 2013 (2)
 Apr 2013 (8)
 Mar 2013 (4)
 Feb 2013 (10)
 Jan 2013 (11)
 Dec 2012 (3)
 Nov 2012 (8)
 Oct 2012 (17)
 Sep 2012 (15)
 Aug 2012 (16)
 Jul 2012 (19)
 Jun 2012 (12)
 May 2012 (12)
 Apr 2012 (12)
 Mar 2012 (12)
 Feb 2012 (13)
 Jan 2012 (14)
 Dec 2011 (19)
 Nov 2011 (21)
 Oct 2011 (31)
 Sep 2011 (12)
 Aug 2011 (8)
 Jul 2011 (7)
 Jun 2011 (3)
 May 2011 (2)
 Apr 2011 (8)
 Mar 2011 (5)
 Feb 2011 (6)
 Jan 2011 (6)
 Dec 2010 (3)
 Nov 2010 (2)
 Oct 2010 (2)
 Sep 2010 (4)
 Aug 2010 (9)
 Jul 2010 (8)
 Jun 2010 (5)
 May 2010 (4)
 Apr 2010 (2)
 Mar 2010 (3)
 Feb 2010 (7)
 Jan 2010 (9)
 Dec 2009 (5)
 Nov 2009 (9)
 Oct 2009 (13)
 Sep 2009 (13)
 Aug 2009 (13)
 Jul 2009 (13)
 Jun 2009 (15)
 May 2009 (15)
 Apr 2009 (14)
 Mar 2009 (13)
 Feb 2009 (10)
 Jan 2009 (12)
 Dec 2008 (6)
 Nov 2008 (8)
 Oct 2008 (2)
 Jul 2008 (1)
 Jun 2008 (6)
 May 2008 (1)
Stacks Image 18