Club Admiralty

v7.2 - moving along, a point increase at a time

Multilitteratus Incognitus

Pondering what to learn next 🤔

PhD ponderings: Tenure...or not to Tenure

http://harvardpolitics.com/covers/higher-education/tenure-tune-up/
I've been thinking about the concept of tenure these days, and the general concept or career prospects for the next 30 years for me.  I've applied to a PhD program in our College of Management focusing on Organizations and Social Change. One of my old professors, who also gave me a recommendation, asked me what I wanted to do with the PhD.  The interesting thing is that with a PhD, and without a PhD I am content in my current job role in academia.  I think a PhD would give me bragging rights (not that I'd want everyone to call me Doctor so-and-so), but it would also open up some avenues for jobs that are normally not open to those without a PhD, including teaching jobs.

It is no secret that there just aren't that many tenure jobs around, and with the adjunctification of higher education, the situation may become worse. Who knows? Maybe I am pessimistic, but I don't see things getting better at this point.  In any case, if I were to earn a PhD, if I didn't get a tenure track job, it would be fine.  One of the things that often comes up in teaching jobs is the whole tenure thing.  From where I stand, tenure seems limiting to me.  Right now, for example, I have seniority in my job which gives me some protection. If I were to apply elsewhere (or be encourage to apply elsewhere), I would probably lose my seniority, but I could balance that off with a higher paycheck (risk/reward).  When looking at tenure track jobs, not only does it seem like will you be getting a lower paycheck, there is the whole publish or perish thing, which means you have to bust your rear to get certain deliverables out the door just so you can tick that little box off.  I am a big fan of researching when you have the passion to do so, not the industrial model that seems to come with publish or perish.

Let's assume that you don't perish, what's the incentive to continue that intellectual production? In most places it's some sort of merit pay, but in all honesty, it seem that, most merit situations aren't that enticing to continue that intellectual production as it was in the pre-tenure years.  Tenure, I feel, is also like a jail cell.  If you fail to get tenure, you need to somehow mask it when applying to other schools.  If you do get tenure, and you end up leaving, then there is either something wrong with you, or your former institution, in which case people are looking for gossip. Since it's not cool to gossip, you get dinged both for gossiping and not gossiping (don't people have anything better to do?). That said, remember that there just aren't that many tenure jobs out there to begin with!

Compare this to working as a professional in higher education, or even outside higher education.  There is much more mobility in non-tenure positions.  People can come and go as they please (provided they have jobs to come and go to), and it's just accepted that people will be changing jobs more frequently as compared to tenured faculty for a variety of reasons; some work related, and some not. Heck, you may just be bored with what you are doing and looking for a breath of fresh air.  Either way you are moving.  This isn't the case with tenured jobs.

So, in thinking about a potential six or seven year PhD journey, I am starting to wonder.  If I am already in a learning community, and my colleagues (most of them PhDs) are interested in helping me develop and grow; and if I am already continuing my learning journey on my own with their guidance - what does a PhD program give me, other than the bragging rights and an edge over other adjuncts?
 Comments
Stacks Image 20

Archive

 Sep 2022 (2)
 Aug 2022 (3)
 Jul 2022 (1)
 Jun 2022 (1)
 May 2022 (2)
 Mar 2022 (2)
 Dec 2021 (2)
 Oct 2021 (1)
 Sep 2021 (1)
 Aug 2021 (2)
 Jul 2021 (1)
 Jun 2021 (1)
 Nov 2020 (1)
 Oct 2020 (1)
 Sep 2020 (1)
 Jun 2020 (2)
 May 2020 (2)
 Mar 2020 (1)
 Jan 2020 (3)
 Nov 2019 (2)
 Sep 2019 (1)
 Aug 2019 (1)
 Jun 2019 (1)
 May 2019 (1)
 Apr 2019 (1)
 Jan 2019 (5)
 Dec 2018 (1)
 Nov 2018 (2)
 Oct 2018 (2)
 Jul 2018 (1)
 May 2018 (1)
 Apr 2018 (2)
 Mar 2018 (2)
 Feb 2018 (1)
 Jan 2018 (1)
 Dec 2017 (2)
 Nov 2017 (1)
 Oct 2017 (2)
 Sep 2017 (2)
 Aug 2017 (2)
 Jul 2017 (4)
 Jun 2017 (7)
 May 2017 (3)
 Mar 2017 (4)
 Feb 2017 (5)
 Jan 2017 (5)
 Dec 2016 (9)
 Nov 2016 (1)
 Oct 2016 (6)
 Sep 2016 (4)
 Aug 2016 (7)
 Jul 2016 (8)
 Jun 2016 (9)
 May 2016 (10)
 Apr 2016 (12)
 Mar 2016 (13)
 Feb 2016 (7)
 Jan 2016 (11)
 Dec 2015 (10)
 Nov 2015 (7)
 Oct 2015 (5)
 Sep 2015 (8)
 Aug 2015 (9)
 Jul 2015 (7)
 Jun 2015 (7)
 May 2015 (15)
 Apr 2015 (2)
 Mar 2015 (10)
 Feb 2015 (4)
 Jan 2015 (7)
 Dec 2014 (5)
 Nov 2014 (13)
 Oct 2014 (10)
 Sep 2014 (8)
 Aug 2014 (8)
 Jul 2014 (5)
 Jun 2014 (5)
 May 2014 (3)
 Apr 2014 (4)
 Mar 2014 (8)
 Feb 2014 (10)
 Jan 2014 (10)
 Dec 2013 (4)
 Nov 2013 (8)
 Oct 2013 (6)
 Sep 2013 (10)
 Aug 2013 (6)
 Jul 2013 (4)
 Jun 2013 (3)
 May 2013 (2)
 Apr 2013 (8)
 Mar 2013 (4)
 Feb 2013 (10)
 Jan 2013 (11)
 Dec 2012 (3)
 Nov 2012 (8)
 Oct 2012 (17)
 Sep 2012 (15)
 Aug 2012 (16)
 Jul 2012 (19)
 Jun 2012 (12)
 May 2012 (12)
 Apr 2012 (12)
 Mar 2012 (12)
 Feb 2012 (13)
 Jan 2012 (14)
 Dec 2011 (19)
 Nov 2011 (21)
 Oct 2011 (31)
 Sep 2011 (12)
 Aug 2011 (8)
 Jul 2011 (7)
 Jun 2011 (3)
 May 2011 (2)
 Apr 2011 (8)
 Mar 2011 (5)
 Feb 2011 (6)
 Jan 2011 (6)
 Dec 2010 (3)
 Nov 2010 (2)
 Oct 2010 (2)
 Sep 2010 (4)
 Aug 2010 (9)
 Jul 2010 (8)
 Jun 2010 (5)
 May 2010 (4)
 Apr 2010 (2)
 Mar 2010 (3)
 Feb 2010 (7)
 Jan 2010 (9)
 Dec 2009 (5)
 Nov 2009 (9)
 Oct 2009 (13)
 Sep 2009 (13)
 Aug 2009 (13)
 Jul 2009 (13)
 Jun 2009 (15)
 May 2009 (15)
 Apr 2009 (14)
 Mar 2009 (13)
 Feb 2009 (10)
 Jan 2009 (12)
 Dec 2008 (6)
 Nov 2008 (8)
 Oct 2008 (2)
 Jul 2008 (1)
 Jun 2008 (6)
 May 2008 (1)
Stacks Image 18